Ohai!

This is why we can't have nice things......

I didn't blame you red I just didn't want to point out soran, MB2 is not my thing ill stick to JA+, I wont try to stop it but I wont exactly advocate it either.

i jsut want these little skirmishes to stop, before they get blown out of proportion :\

it is done....

Rejected. I will not accept a person who just wants to play in one of our RP factions, wich you guys can totally control and even accept people from outside the clan. The clan appliance is for people who want to join JvS, not RvE. And he clearly doesnt want to join the clan, just RvE, i dunno if you didnt notice it, but its not the same thing.

Rejections overturned until you three have a proper reason aside from being butthurt. I'm EXTREMELY disappointed in you three(Ara, Haize, Dray) for rejecting him out of hand. You know we don't accept multi-clanning for MB2, so someone wanting to join us because they play MB2 is perfectly fine.

Aardvark wrote:Rejections overturned until you three have a proper reason aside from being butthurt. I'm EXTREMELY disappointed in you three(Ara, Haize, Dray) for rejecting him out of hand. You know we don't accept multi-clanning for MB2, so someone wanting to join us because they play MB2 is perfectly fine.

Wich part of, "I dont want to join JvS, i want to join RvE" did you not understand? So basically, he only wants to join a part of the clan. Im perfectly fine with him wanting to join to play MB2, IF he could englobe JvS as a whole in his commitment to a clan, but it seems thats not the case, so until he says he can join us as a whole, and not just as to play MB2 and join the RP faction, im fine with that. I have to accept people who play MB2 even thou i dont, because they are part of this clan, such as i enjoy partaking with the people who play base in this clan. He only wants one of those parts, and not enravel with us as a unity.

If i hear from him differently to his position in commitment, i might reconsider, but as such, rejection stands.

Rejection doesn't stand, he wants to join the clan, even if it's only part of it. He's being honest about his reasons and not lying which I think you should respect, most people don't play both, they play one or the other. You have no reason to reject as even if he mainly wants in for RvE, he still wants into the clan. Now get over your butthurt and move on.

Not butthurt, i respect him, rejection stands. He says he just wants to join RvE, and he specifically said, i dont want to join JvS, i want to join RvE. He tells me he wants to join JvS, i let him in. Simple as that.

And no, you cannot rebute my rejection. Senate status, not councilor.

I can refute it if you have no reason, and I assert that you don't, especially considering that you KNOW they're working on making it official.

Aardvark wrote:I can refute it if you have no reason, and I assert that you don't, especially considering that you KNOW they're working on making it official.

Working on it. I gave reason, the fact that in your cunundrums, it is unreasonable, is of no matter to me, since i have place its logicality, and by logicality, it holds. He said he doesnt want, i reject.

BTW, for the MB2 people, you have to create Charter proposals too. I hope you remembered that the Charter is heavily created by jka default values, and thus, you need to work on it too, for compatibility issues.

Aureus wrote:we did

And we are working on the Acts, just clearing up a few things before we get to that

You should pass it thru Aard, he clears out the more major incompatibilities the fastest, then we can discuss the higher issues it may have.

This is going to be one blanket Act Dray, the wording will be longer then some of my CoaJ segments. And I argue that by saying he wants to join RvE, a part of JvS he is saying he wants to join JvS and thus the wording saying he doesn't is simply a bad way of saying he's not interested in JA+.

Faction and ranking up are of little matter to me, im concerned with discrepancies with core ideals, wich need addressing in the original Charter too, but its best to work out the premises now, then focus on the major parts.

Aardvark wrote:This is going to be one blanket Act Dray, the wording will be longer then some of my CoaJ segments. And I argue that by saying he wants to join RvE, a part of JvS he is saying he wants to join JvS and thus the wording saying he doesn't is simply a bad way of saying he's not interested in JA+.

If i could find Champs post he specifically said we can Reject people for no reason any time we want, but thats not the case here as you can see ALL three of us rejected him for the same reason maybe stated it in different ways but basically the same reason. Besides if you can over turn our rejections what is the point in letting us being able to reject people in the first place?

No, you need a reason, it's not written down, but it's implied. And you're all just butthurt because he's more interested in MB2 then JA+. You guys know exactly what he meant.

i FAIL to see how i could possibly care, when i have stopped playing JKA months ago(mind you, hardware issues, not because i dont want it completely)

Caim wrote:Why do you want to join JvS?

- I don't, I wanna join RvE

/sigh......