RPG fight

Knights of the Old Republic series, first part was game of the year 2003
graphic: C
sound: B+
story: B+
gameplay: B
fun: A

Mass Effect series, bioware's as kotor, but instead of lightsaber you use guns, more realistic
graphics: A
sound: A
story: B+
gameplay: B
fun: A

Oblivion (Elder Scroll IV) and its expansion, game of the year 2006, unique style of RP but not original, big open world
graphics: A
sound: B+
story: B+
gameplay: B
fun: A

Neverwinter Nights 2, original old school RP with great graphics, multiplayer but not MMO, and as well toolset that allows players to create worlds themselves, bioware got its fingers into this game as well
graphics: A-
sound: A
story: A
gameplay: A-
fun: A

Aion, a MMORPG, pay to play, slowly kills WoW that once had more then 11 millions players, great customization of character but a bit looks gay, you can fly with wings
graphics: C
sound: B-
story: C
gameplay: C+
fun: B-

Those are my personal rates of games, for me winner is Neverwinter Nights 2, then Mass Effect, then Oblivion, then KOTOR, then Aion. What do you think about those games, you can rate them in my form, vote or just say opinion. Which game of listed is best for you?

Never played any of those except Kotor lol, so guess my vote

KOTOR - All A+ for me. For its age its kickass.
Mass Effect - All cool.
NWN2 - Havent played much ,cant vote.
Aion - most idiotic game ever.
Oblivion - Great game.

My vote: KOTOR.

lol cogger ur xire profile says that nwn2 wins oblivion for 123 hours xD

Well Oblivion with mods easilly beats all the other games. I have only played Oblivion and KOTOR from these games.

In my oppinion KOTOR's story is better than Oblivion's, but Oblivion haves better gameplay.

As stated above, add some mods to TES IV Oblivion and you can make it 2 times better

I voted KOTOR. No game in that list left as great an impression as that game..

KOTOR spoiler below:

Spoiler:

what would come on second, third ... place champ, cogger?

nah, those are not so good, i played better games so i won't vote

I haven't played any of those games but I voted for SWTOR

Its KOTOR ,not TOR.

honstly
its a hard choice for me

in the console department Kotor has a much better story then oblivion simply cause console oblivion had no community to add fixes

in the PC department id give it to oblivion for the fact that i must have quadrupled the game's size with fixes and massive amounts of models ,gameplay fixes, story additions not to mention the official expansions and addons, houses the epic open world addon which made it fell like morrowind
and the fact i used that mod to add morrowind to my oblivion which basically made the game the most epic place in the world
plus the mods that actually added areas to the other places like daggerfall

when i got done i had the entire TES world im talking this whole thing with buildings and places almost
and if u didnt know in oblivion all those places are in the game without buildngs but with the land so if u disable the borders u can explore the open lands

I tried playing mass effect but it bored me to tears in the beginning and I didnt really want to continue playing it...

Kotor was one of the best games I have ever played. The story is just so great especially
SPOILER:

Spoiler:

One of the biggest plot twists ever....

Opinion point of view is useless. Ill try being objective.

First, Aion is not a RPG, its an MMO, cannot in anyway be compared to the others. Whole different game. KOTOR by far is the most well conveived game. Neverwinter and Oblivion fail for me for one simple reason: They are medieval RPGs, wich means, baawwwwwwwww they just copied this idea for the 1000th time in gaming history. Keep in mind KOTOR was the first major star wars rpg. Completely original idea, as well as completely original scenario. I dont know for sure if the Old Republic was highly written by the time the game came out, but still, it popularized it. Neverwinter....ok, its not SO much as the traditional medieval RPG, but still has that shit in it. Oblivion.....ok, I DONT COUNT MODS, IF YOU NEED A MOD TO MAKE A GAME GOOD, THEN ITS NOT REALLY A GOOD GAME IS IT? not saying its bad, just saying if you need a mod for it to be better than the other games, it fails. Mass Effect....oh wait this is just a medieval RPG but in the future. But fuck it, its damn good game. Not in terms of the main plot, but the environment and place your in, one of most original ideals ever. Specially the alien societies.


1.KOTOR
2.Mass Effect
3.Neverwinter Nights 2
4.Oblivion
5.Secret of Mana(kidding, this is actually 2nd, it just falls to 5th cause it wasnt on the list)

Ðaaaaa wrote:I tried playing mass effect but it bored me to tears in the beginning and I didnt really want to continue playing it...

Kotor was one of the best games I have ever played. The story is just so great especially
SPOILER:

Spoiler:

One of the biggest plot twists ever....

Fuck yeah I forgot about that.

I love oblivion, I can see Deadlys arguments, but I think the story line of KOTOR was 10x more epic than Oblivion. Oblivion was a fun game, no doubt with even more replay value than KOTOR. But in terms of epic moments in gaming history, KOTOR beats oblivion by far and for that gets my vote.

indeed champ kotor definatly has the best base story out of all those choices

infact i never bothered to mod kotor much for fear of unbalancing it

i have modded Kotor 2 but only in terms of models, i hated the faces they had. But i never modded KOTOR 1, oh i modded one thing, Skip Taris, BUT ONLY because when you replay it, its boring part. but i swear to God, the Taris part of the game is one of THE best introductory chapters ive seen in a game. it is so godamn immersive.

Damnnn i forgot about Secret of Mana. That was a kick ass game my friends and I used to play.

go Kotor.......

Hmmm I wonder How brinks gonna be.

i voted for KOTOR cuz Bastila is hot

EVERYONE LOVES ME!

KOTOR was so awesome.

The first time I got my saber, I was all like

Then when

Spoiler:

I was like


The combat was so well balanced too. The second game Is great too, but not nearly as great as the first. Although more saber colors for me was a WinRAR.

you couldnt wait to use that smile cld u thing xD
yeah kotor was best game for me too, i beat both 20+ times, thats why somehow it became boring to me and other games won it, but feeling i had after first play was awesome.